I spent the better part of the morning on Friday reviewing my student’s standardized test scores and here is what I learned:
- My 2013/14 8th graders scored generally better than my 2012/13 8th graders in English Language Arts
- My deep analysis of interim assessment data and focus on reader response writing seemed to pay off in 2013/14
- Some students made great gains
- Some students scores dropped from 7th grade to 8th grade
- 69% of my students were proficient while only 44% of the 8th graders at the school were proficient
- 79% of 8th graders in the state were proficient; while I’m narrowing the gap in my school, my students are still falling behind when compared to the state
Now, none of this really matters at this point. These students are off in high school with some other teacher looking at their scores who knows very little about them at this stage in the school year. To compare the 2012/13 students with the 2013/14 students seems odd to me since one of the classes I taught last year had higher scores overall than my classes the previous year. I had more special needs students in 2012/13 and in 2013/14 I had zero special needs students and a handful of English Language Learners. Also, the students I had in 2012/13 had different teachers in 7th grade than the students in 2013/14 did. How can I truly tell that what I did differently from one year to the next made a difference? There are some other clues, like interim assessment data that I received throughout the school year that do point to successes in my practice, but overall, to look at my data from one year to the next is comparing apples to oranges.
And this is why standardized test scores are meaningless to teachers. Administrators, politicians, and parents want to hold us accountable, but how can you hold us accountable when we test students in the Spring and don’t receive the results until the Fall while we have a whole new group of students in front of us? My point is that while the scores may tell us a little bit about our teaching practice, they tell us a lot more about our students; and by that time it’s too late. I’m so proud of the students who made gains last year in my class, I’m also proud that I had a higher percentage of students proficient than my school did, but I won’t ever get the chance to see what went wrong with the kids who’s scores dropped or did not score proficient. To reasonably hold teachers accountable for this data, we either need to receive the data while the students are in front of us or teach the same cohort for more than one year; otherwise, its a total waste of time and money.